The Competitive Psychology of Pricing for E-Commerce

Pricing for e-commerce is a tricky beast. You need to account for competition with other sellers, but you don’t want to de-value your products in a race-to-the-bottom. Purely competitive pricing can lead to disappointing results: you might not sell enough to compensate for offering the lowest prices.

A profitable pricing strategy involves considering not only your competitions’ prices, but also your customers’ motivations. Sellers use their understanding of potential buyers’ decision-making processes to create pricing that encourages purchases.

Different types of companies have been experimenting with psychological pricing for years, but it’s important to understand how it applies to e-commerce where competition among online sellers is rampant. When sellers set prices in a way that motivates buyers to purchase, without devaluing their products, they are able to win more sales than competitors.

To help sellers gain this competitive edge, we’ll take a look at the most effective psychological pricing principles and tactics.

Quick takeaways:

  • Stronger branding can help you define your unique value proposition and price according to the quality you’re able to provide.
  • Use buyer personas to understand your buyers’ wants and what makes them tick.
  • Social proof tactics such as reviews or inventory information can help establish trust in your product.
  • By utilizing the psychology of numbers, you can strategically price your products to appeal to a wider audience.

Sellers who employ these psychological pricing strategies can maintain their brand’s reputation and target their ideal buyers without engaging in race-to-the-bottom pricing.

Pricing For E-Commerce: Branding

The amount a customer is willing to pay boils down to their perception of your brand. If you want to charge higher prices than your competitors, you have to clearly convey why your product is more useful and valuable to buyers through your unique value proposition.

A unique value proposition indicates how a product is different from its competitors and why it’s the best choice for solving a buyer’s problem. This promise of what a product offers signals to buyers how much they should pay for their product.

To make sales at their desired price point, sellers should focus on messaging that conveys why their product is high-quality and worth more than their competitors’. When sellers instill positive perceptions of their brand, they gain their customers’ trust and are able to charge profitable prices to buyers who are willing to pay for the promised value.

Tips for Stronger Branding and More Profitable Pricing

To get started, here are a few tips for aligning your pricing with your brand.

1. Define your unique value proposition

If you haven’t already, you need to identify what sets your brand apart from competitors so that buyers feel justified in paying your set price. Apple’s branding, for example, positions the iPhone 13 Pro as “Hollywood in your pocket,” so consumers feel comfortable paying premium prices for it. By comparing the quality of their camera to that of Hollywood’s, they’re demonstrating superiority in a photo & video driven society.

Apple iPhone 13 Pro campaign demonstrates Apple's superior camera quality, comparable to Hollywood's capabilities.

People are more willing to pay for unique value that they can’t get anywhere else, so sellers need to clearly show what their brand offers through their messaging. Sellers who are unsure of whether they’re effectively communicating their value proposition should send a survey to buyers and gauge how customers perceive their brand.

2. Price to reflect your product’s quality

Studies have shown that consumers infer quality from price. When buyers encounter high prices, they often assume that the product must be a premium item without any other information. In the example below, one of Tumi’s best selling suitcases is also one of their most expensive ones. Why? Because their buyers assume that it’s one of their highest-quality products.

Tumi's premium suitcase demonstrates the value of appropriately pricing for e-commerce products online.

Sellers should aim to offer pricing that reflects the level of quality they’ve promised and be wary of devaluing their product by offering the lowest price.

Pricing for E-Commerce: Buyer’s Wants

When customers shop online, they have an idea of how much they want to pay and how badly they need certain products. Sellers have to price according to these desires to ensure that customers will complete their purchases.

Sellers who don’t pay attention to what their customers care about won’t have a sense of their buyers’ willingness to pay. Without this knowledge, you can’t ensure that your buyers will find your price acceptable and purchase your product. You also won’t know how to tap into consumers’ concerns on your pricing page and push them to make their purchases.

Tips to understand what your customers want to pay

Your understanding of what your buyers want should inform not only your price amount, but also how you present the price with text. Here are a few strategies to get started:

1. Develop and consistently update your buyer personas

Create profiles for your customer types that identify their buying concerns, what motivates them to buy your product, their income, and other insights that will help you understand their willingness to pay. With this knowledge, you’ll feel secure in what you are charging for your product and more confident that you will make sales.

By building buyer personas, you could become more confident in what you are charging for your e-commerce brand.

For more guidance on collecting persona info, check out our guide to creating buyer profiles here.

2. Invoke urgency on the pricing page to encourage purchases

Feelings of FOMO can prompt consumers to buy products more if the items seem scarce. Look for opportunities to highlight urgency on your pricing page to encourage buyers to make a purchase.

For example, you might include the number of items left in stock or the number of items sold. Another urgency tactic that eBay uses is to show the number of people watching the product by the price (bottom right).

Creating a sense of urgency around your products could offer a stronger sense of pricing for e-commerce.

Because buyers care so much about not missing out, creating a sense of urgency on your pricing page will convince consumers to make a purchase.

Pricing for E-Commerce: Social Proof

Online shopping requires a leap of faith since you can’t interact with your merchant. With less reason to trust online companies, buyers look to the experiences of others before making a purchase. Considering the opinions of other buyers, consumers decide whether they’ll pay a seller’s price through the phenomenon of social proof.

Social proof is the psychological tendency of assuming that others’ actions reflect correct behavior. The phenomenon can cause a dramatic boost in sales when consumers see evidence of product satisfaction, such as positive product reviews.

While the price of a product itself can’t tap into social proof, there are plenty of opportunities on the pricing page to show how consumers positively perceive your brand and encourage purchases.

Tips for justifying your prices with social proof

Here are a few ideas of what to include near your price to tap into social proof:

1. Indicate whether many people have bought your product

If you have a best-selling product, highlight how popular it is near its price. Consumers who see that many people have bought the item will feel more validated in paying the price you’ve set. B&H uses this tactic in the example below by placing a “top seller” badge close to the price.

By placing a “top seller” badge close to the price, companies can justify their pricing for e-commerce products.

With this proximity, consumers are positioned to positively evaluate the price after seeing that so many people have bought the product.

2. Place customer ratings and reviews close to pricing

Consumers are more encouraged to buy an item when they see that the product has high ratings. Most product pages take this motivation into account by placing the item’s rating right next to its prices. Sellers who want to encourage buyers even further to make a purchase should also consider placing the reviews close to the price as well, like in the example of Dyson’s cordless vacuum cleaner below.

Dyson utilizes customer reviews on their product pages to justify pricing for e-commerce items.

By seeing others positively receive your product, consumers have more context to understand a price and feel more comfortable making the purchase.

Pricing for E-Commerce: Numbers

Consumers don’t consider pricing on purely practical terms. The arrangement of numbers in a price, regardless of the amount, has a huge impact on buyers’ willingness to pay due to some basic human psychology about how we judge things quantitively.

The framing of prices — how many digits they contain, which numbers they end on — will often make amounts seem more or less expensive to buyers. Prices that seem more expensive are less appealing to consumers, thrifty or not, because humans are naturally loss-averse. If two prices are almost equal in amounts but one is framed to seem much greater, consumers are geared to choose the one that seems cheaper.

Considering buyers’ loss-averse nature, sellers want to make sure they are framing their prices to seem as painless as possible.

Tips for Painless Pricing

Here are a few tips for framing your price to seem less costly:

1. Take advantage of the “left-digit” effect

Known as charm pricing, researchers found that a price ending in nine is perceived to be much cheaper than a price one cent higher ending in zero. This effect, however, only works if the left digit of the price decreases. Western countries read from left to right, so their perception of the price is affected by the left number seen first. $4.69 won’t seem cheaper than $4.60, but $29.99 will seem cheaper than $30.00, like in the example below.

In their strategy of pricing for e-commerce, Amazon uses the charm pricing effect to make products seem cheaper.

Using the left-digit effect, sellers should opt to end their prices with a nine so that buyers perceive the price to be a good deal and feel encouraged to purchase their product.

2. Use fewer syllables in your price

Researchers found in a study that prices with more syllables seem much higher than those with fewer. For instance, $77.39 (8 syllables) in the example below is going to seem much more expensive to buyers than $77 (4 syllables) would.

By using simpler numbers when pricing for e-commerce, the brain believes that the product is cheaper.

With long prices, consumers perceive a product to be too costly and, avoiding loss, won’t buy it. Instead, sellers should aim to keep their pricing simple with as few syllables as possible to encourage purchases.

Consider your buyers, not just your competitors

Sustainable, successful pricing involves taking more than your competitors’ rates into account — you also have to consider what drives your buyers to make a purchase. Psychological pricing allows sellers to stay ahead of competitors without needing to resort to low, unprofitable prices.

When you price your products in a way that you know will be attractive to your customers, you’ll encourage purchases while strengthening your brand, your understanding of your customers, and your product positioning.

Over to You

E-Commerce brands need great content if they want to connect with their audience and beat their competition. That’s why copywriting services could benefit E-Commerce companies today!

The team at Marketing Insider Group can deliver you optimized, ready-to-publish content every single week for one year (or more!). To learn more, check out our SEO Blog Writing Service or schedule a quick 15 minute consultation with me to get started.

Haley McDevitt

Haley McDevitt is a Director of Marketing Strategy and Client Services at Marketing Insider Group, a leading Content Marketing Agency. She has worked in marketing and communications at Fortune 500 companies such as Qurate Retail, Inc (QVC, HSN, Zulily) and Universal Health Services, Inc. Her part-time hustle is her photography business, a lifestyle & wedding photography brand. Connect with her on LinkedIn.