Content Marketing
5 Common Traits Of The Best Content Marketing Companies

5 Common Traits Of The Best Content Marketing Companies

September 30, 2015
5 min read

5 Content Marketing Traits Making the decision to outsource some of your content marketing needs could be the best decision you’ll make for your brand. Of course, you’ll have to choose your partners wisely to ensure they’ll produce the type of content that is on point, and will elevate your message to develop stronger relationships with your audience.

“When you’re a brand looking for a content partner, there are many attributes to keep in mind but a few come to the forefront,” says Georgia Galanoudis, managing director, Imprint, a Sullivan Content Lab.“Recent research from The Content Council and AdAge uncovered several of the biggest marketer challenges with content marketing: the creation of quality/engaging content, lack of time, not enough resources, and demonstrating ROI. Any content firm you enlist needs to help you tackle those challenges head on.”

We connected with two content marketing company directors for a look at some of the unique attributes that keep their clients coming back to them. Find out what these qualities are, and how to identify them as you do your own content marketing company research.

1. A stable of professional content creators

The last thing you want to do is get mixed up with a content mill that produces tons of drivel just to fill up your website. Instead, aligning yourself with content teams comprised of professional writers will give your brand credibility.

I take pride in my team of writers,” says Gina LaGuardia, owner of Gina LaGuardia Editorial Services, a content and social media marketing firm with clients including Chase Bank, BELLA Magazine,, and RealPage. “Since most of my group has been working together for 5+ years, I’m able to instantly assign the right team member to the right projects, and they all work well together. Even though we’re all freelancers with prestigious credits, projects, and responsibilities, we remain a cohesive group that is aware of each other’s assignments, shares sources, collaborates, and brainstorms our way to the best quality content for our clients,” she says.

What to look for:

Seek out a content firm that boasts a connected teamwork-based approach, says LaGuardia, and ask to learn more about the professional content creators with whom you’ll be working. “In the last year or so, I’ve started integrating information about my team’s writers at the proposal and presentation stage of my negotiations with clients,” she says. That’s because clients increasingly expect to work with writers who have their own well-respected professional persona or brand.

Our 35+ custom-content writers are established influencers in their fields, many working for decades in a particular industry before they began writing about it. They are experts and professionals at a fundamental level so that when they create content for our clients, the job is always well-researched, thoughtful, accurate, and unique.

2. Measurability

Although you have a need for someone to help scale your content, more specifically you need results-driven content. Choosing a content marketing company that has a game plan for measuring results and tying them back to your goals is important.

“Great content isn’t created in a vacuum,” says Kathryn Hawkins, principal and editorial lead at Eucalypt Media, a content marketing agency with a remote office in Maine that focuses on content marketing strategies and content creation for national clients including LinkedIn, The Atlantic, and B2B tech startups. “We need to showcase the positive impact that it’s having on the client’s business, whatever their overall goals might be.”

What to look for:

While it does depend on the main goal of your content strategy, key metrics (or KPIs) for content marketing to look at typically include elements such as a rise in organic search traffic, increased search engine visibility, new subscribers to a mailing list or white paper, and guest blog post publications or mentions from established websites and publications, says Hawkins.

When we begin an engagement, we interview our clients to learn about the metrics that are most important to them, and track that data on an ongoing basis,” she says. Ask if the firm provides reports on elements such as monthly search ranking data, details of new mentions or guest post acceptances on other blogs or websites, data on organic search traffic and the most popular content, and details of new subscribers, as well as other KPIs, she suggests.

Finally, be sure the content marketing company can also put those results into context, and use them in discussions on how to optimize results even further in the future.

3. Accessibility

Whether you choose a content marketing firm that’s small or large is irrelevant. What should be more of a concern is if you’ll have a point person who will collaborate with you and be accessible should any issues come up.

Accessibility is being available to hear clients out and to assure that their need or task is top priority, and – more importantly – that you value and care about the project at hand as much as they do,” says LaGuarida. In other words, seeking out a content firm that places value on attention and dedication is something clients must do when exploring their options.

What to look for:

Ask a lot of direct questions regarding how much time and manpower a firm will be dedicating to you. Questions like: How can I best reach you (email, text, messenger, Skype, etc.)? Will I have a specific editor or project manager available to me to discuss questions? At what stages of the workflow do you encourage such ongoing discussions? How long do revisions take?

“A firm may produce the best content out of the gate, but if they aren’t there to talk through a client’s concerns or suggestions, I guarantee the material will start to look tainted as the hours and days pass,” says LaGuardia.

4. Case studies and testimonials

Even if you get a good vibe from a content marketing company, it never hurts to do some additional sleuthing by asking to see samples of their work and actual testimonials from clients that show their satisfaction. Most quality content services will offer this up front, but if not, be sure to ask.

“We believe that social proof and work samples are both powerful tools,” says Hawkins, who points prospective clients to reviews of her agency on the third-party site Clutch Research. Eucalypt also spotlights case studies in different industries on its website.

What to look for:

Look for client case studies and testimonials on an agency’s website or third-party platforms like LinkedIn – testimonials should include the client’s full name, so that you can confirm their validity. If the project involves content development, it’s also important to get samples of actual deliverables performed for other clients, suggests Hawkins.

5. Support 

There’s a big difference between just hiring a freelancer or two and outsourcing your content to an agency. When choosing a content marketing company, you want to be sure there is a mix of talent and experience in the core content marketing disciplines — editorial, subject matter expertise, strategy, design, and analytics — inside that agency, says Galanoudis. “Having a staff on board that has a broad, multi-channel experience and deep understanding of the nuances that go into creating and designing content that meets your business, channel, and audience objectives is critical,” she says.

What to look for:

Depending on your needs and your own in-house capabilities, choose a firm that helps fill the specific voids in your marketing plan. That could mean a soup-to-nuts agency that can handle content, design, and social media deployment. Or, you may decide that you need more help with a specific area of your strategy, say, video content. Either way, know that not all content marketing companies are one-size-fits-all, so don’t assume they’re all the same.

By putting the research time in at the beginning and making sure prospective content marketing companies meet the above criteria, you’ll be able to forge ahead with superior brand content in no time.

4 thoughts on “5 Common Traits Of The Best Content Marketing Companies

  1. Manmay Mehta

    Couldn’t agree more. Writers are asset to any organizations for content marketing. They must possess the ability to create an extraordinarily interesting content that engages audience.
    I’ll add one more trait and that’s design. A good Designer is a manager’s delight. No matter how good your content is, if it doesn’t look attractive or have images that let readers visualize the whole article, your efforts will go in vein.
    And the last but not the least is the CMS.
    Content Management must be perfect because if you don’t have proper CMS Development in place, you’ll lose out on many important things such as customer engagement, better user experience and bounce rate.

  2. Michael Brenner

    Thanks Manmay, I agree on all points. Great writing, design and an awesome customer experience all combine to form the foundation of effective content marketing.

  3. Christoph C. Cemper – Impactana

    I guess most people underestimate Content Marketing in the sense of thinking that putting out no matter what leads to success. But publishing content for the sake of publishing content is not enough. You have to figure out what attracts attention. Otherwise, you are going to waste your time and your money. So even though I agree that all points given are essential, in my opinion number 2, measurability, is the most important.

    How should you know what to publish successfully in the future without checking what resonated well in the past? To measure the resonance and user engagement of your own and also your competitors’ content, I created a tool called Impactana ( Checking out what works for your competitors could potentially give you inspiration for your work. We offer a free version of Impactana at the moment; maybe you want to have a look?

  4. Michael Brenner

    Thanks Christoph, I agree measurement is really important.

    Mentioning products in comments is normally verboten and usually gets caught in spam filters but in this case I’m pushing through to give our readers a chance to make their own decision. Best of luck!

Get a Free Consultation
for Content Marketing

Michael Brenner

Michael Brenner is an international keynote speaker, author of "Mean People Suck" and "The Content Formula", and Founder of Marketing Insider Group. Recognized as a Top Content Marketing expert and Digital Marketing Leader, Michael leverages his experience from roles in sales and marketing for global brands like SAP and Nielsen, as well as his leadership in leading teams and driving growth for thriving startups. Today, Michael delivers empowering keynotes on marketing and leadership, and facilitates actionable workshops on content marketing strategy. Connect with Michael today.

Related Posts

Content Marketing Overcoming 3 Common Challenges of Omnichannel Marketing

Overcoming 3 Common Challenges of Omnichannel Marketing

Aug 28, 2023
5 min read
Sales Alignment 8 Common Sales Mistakes That Need to Stop NOW

8 Common Sales Mistakes That Need to Stop NOW

Sep 1, 2023
5 min read
Content Marketing How SaaS Companies Win with Content Marketing?

How SaaS Companies Win with Content Marketing?

Oct 11, 2023
28 min read