Content Quality Vs. Content Quantity – The Great Content Debate

content quality vs quantity debate
content quality vs quantity debate

Content quality vs. content quantity. How much content is enough? How good does it need to be? I wrote a version of this post 7 years ago. Then, I was the closing keynote for a content marketing event recently where I realized the debate still rages. So here is an update!

Every business struggles with the question of content quality vs. quantity. Marketers have always struggled with. I have seen the argument from ad execs and agencies who whether they should buy more reach or frequency (or even worse, media impressions.)

I have dealt with this as both a sales person and as a demand gen marketer sending leads to sales. Do we send enough quantity of leads to satisfy sales or do we send them quality leads that convert to purchase?

And content marketers in every industry are now facing the same dilemma: How much blog content should we create, how often should we publish, how long should it be, how much should it cost, and how good does it need to be?

Quick Takeaways:

  • Studies show that quantity of content does matter when it comes to web traffic. Quality, on the other hand, is critical for search visibility and conversions.
  • There doesn’t need to be a trade-off between content quality and quantity. With a few tweaks to your content strategy, you can have the best of both worlds.
  • Use your expertise as a thought leader and repurpose previous content to create fresh new perspectives on your industry.
  • When it comes to content, quality vs quantity is not a dichotomy. You can have your cake and eat it too! You don’t have to chose between the two.

Can There Be a Balance?

Of course, you need to straddle the line between creating enough content to increase your share of customer conversations vs. the need to represent your unique point of view and differentiate yourself from the competition.

As my friend Doug Kessler from Velocity Partners has said, we need to “Stop Creating Crap.” But that doesn’t mean we need to create less.

I think it’s easy to take the side of quality in the debate. Of course we have to create engaging, helpful and entertaining content. And it has to live up to the standards that your brand reputation requires.

As content marketers, we have to produce content that reaches our target audience, that engages them and inspires them to action.

But we have to do all this at a scale that impacts the business. We cannot produce one great piece of content every month when the shelf life of content in today’s world is a few days at best and a few seconds at worse.

So do we need more content or better content? We need more, better content. 

As big of a stickler as I am about quality content, my answer might surprise you when it comes to the debate about content quality vs. quantity. In fact, I haven’t changed my mind much over the years since I first spoke about this topic at the Content Marketing Institute back in 2013.

That’s because I’ve studied the data… Quantity matters. But don’t just take my word for it.

Marketing giant HubSpot’s research agrees with my own studies, as do many others. There’s a sweet spot when it comes to blog posting, as you can see from the graph below.

More better content

Companies that post 2 to 4 times a week (eight to 16 posts per month) show a huge increase in inbound traffic – anywhere from 2 to almost 4 times as much.

You can have the best of both worlds. It only takes a few minutes more to run your blog post through a grammar checker like Grammarly. It only takes an extra hour or so to track down the statistics that prove your points.

“Deadlines are the greatest source of inspiration.” ~ Mark Twain

I truly believe Mark Twain that setting a publishing schedule helps us to create better content. So we have to start by defining a quantity goal. We have to start with a dedicated and committed publishing schedule that will allow us to make a dent in the share of online customer conversations your prospects are having. Thinking like a publisher means you have to force deadlines on yourself.

So once we pick our publishing schedule, we then demand high standards of quality for each piece that we push out.

Volume has advantages as well. More content equals more insights into what works. More content equals more opportunities to drive social engagement. More content equals more opportunities to answer your customers’ top questions.

You Don’t Have to Be a Writer to Pump Out Quality Content at Scale

You already live and breathe whatever industry you’ve made your life’s work. It doesn’t take much more effort to put that passion into words.

If you’re not much for writing, you can put out superb content through video or audio posts. Or, you could always jot down your thoughts in rough form and let a blog writing service polish it for you.

You have expertise in your field. Sharing that expertise with people who need it is never “crap.” You only need to frame that masterpiece in proper grammar, search engine-gulping keywords, and empathetic language that wins hearts as well as minds.

I’m not that far from Kessler’s view than you might think. He put my thoughts into words in an interview with Ceralytics, speaking about the challenge of producing quality content – and doing it consistently. He said, “If you’re not telling a differentiated story, you’re not going to be able to deliver consistent results over time.”

What he meant by “differentiated story” was exactly the point I drive home to our clients. Setting yourself apart as a thought leader in your niche and creating content around your expertise is the key to content marketing success.

When you use your expertise as a springboard for content ideas, you do two things.

  • You limit your content to specific areas, helping you rank better in searches for the products and services you offer.
  • You simplify the content creation process by producing content on topics that you are comfortable with.

Not only will the content you produce rank higher, but you can also produce more of it, easily taking your content production level up to that sweet spot of two to four posts per week. That’s not just for people who find it easy to write.

We’ve worked with subject matter experts – leaders in their fields – who were either non-native English speakers or found it difficult to put pen to paper. We’ve discovered that there are always alternative ways to help these industry leaders to get the message out.

If you find it difficult to put your thoughts into writing, try recording a video or audio version of your thoughts. A blog writing service can turn a transcript of your ideas into a top-quality article.

Repurpose Older Content to Increase Posting Frequency

In addition to focusing on your expertise to come up with blog post ideas, we recommend that companies repurpose their older content to broaden their reach. The number of ways you can reuse previous content is limited only by your imagination. With this kind of content marketing strategy, you’ll soon bump up your production to a whole new level.

Change the channel: Not everyone likes to read. That includes your target customers. Turn your blog posts into videos, your videos into podcast episodes. Create infographics from those statistics you’ve so meticulously researched for your last blog post. Find your best-performing content and distribute it in a variety of forms to reach those with a different learning style.

Switch perspectives: There are so many angles to every topic within your niche that a single blog post, video, or podcast can’t cover. Take this topic, for example. We’ve covered the “why” – but not so much the “how” one can find the time to produce that much content in a week’s time. A future post could cover time-saving writing techniques and tools that can help you and your team produce more quality content in less time.

Use readers’ comments and questions on previous posts as a springboard: Since the whole point of content marketing is to answer your target customers’ questions and solve their problems, why not use some of their comments on your posts as ideas for future posts? You’ll be addressing their concerns – and when you do, they’ll be more likely to move further along their customer journey. Also, keep track of your followers’ comments on your social media posts for even more ideas. In fact, if you have quite a few people with the same concern, it might be worth your time to hold a webinar on the topic.

repurpose content

Once you prime the content pump, I can just about guarantee you that you can get to at least two blog posts per week. It’s your passion – your life’s work. You’ve got this.

Then, as you become more comfortable sharing your expertise, you’ll find yourself publishing even more often. Before you know it, you’ll be publishing four posts a week and getting the kind of web traffic that boosts your ROI to unbelievable heights.

If you are ready to get more traffic to your site with quality content published consistently – and often – check out our Content Builder Service. Set up a quick consultation, and I’ll send you a free PDF version of my books. Get started today – and generate

Let me know what you think in the comments below.

Michael Brenner  is a Top CMO, Content Marketing and Digital Marketing Influencer, an international keynote speaker, author of "Mean People Suck" and "The Content Formula" and he is the CEO and Founder of Marketing Insider Group, a leading Content Marketing Agency . He has worked in leadership positions in sales and marketing for global brands like SAP and Nielsen, as well as for thriving startups. Today, Michael helps build successful content marketing programs for leading brands and startups alike. Subscribe here for regular updates.

14 thoughts on “Content Quality Vs. Content Quantity – The Great Content Debate

  1. I think the move toward content marketing is a very significant advance in marketing and the entire business,customer relationship and helps to improve your business.

  2. “Deadlines are the greatest source of inspiration.” That’s personally why I’m striving for quantity right now, because if I let myself wait till I’m “inspired”, I’d never write! But if I sit down to write because omg-I-have-to-post-today, I’ll always find something to write.

    1. Unmana, that is exactly what I do. I have tried to get ahead of my schedule and it never happens. Even when I make a list of “ideas” when I go back, I can’t seem to get into the same brain pattern. This quote is my new mantra.

  3. Let’s be honest… if we don’t impose a quantity goal, then you’ll never end up posting anything at all. Readers are creatures of habit and if you post in a regular schedule, they’ll look forward to reading your material when the deadline hits, regardless of whether it’s good/bad or relevant.

  4. Michael:

    Great post as usual – This debate has been happening for quite some time and I’ve never heard anyone mention what I consider more important than quality or quantity. That’s “consistency.”

    Consistency in quality (whatever that may be) and consistency in quantity (whatever that may be) sets expectations for readers and Google. I think it’s time to inject “consistency” into the debate. Now I’m motivated to write a post. Thanks Michael!

    @ChadPollitt

    1. Great point Chad. At content marketing world, we talked about how we all know the answer is not A. Quality or B. Quantity but C. both. Maybe consistency is the best way to explain what “both” means.

  5. I always go for quality, but if you cannot achieve quality without the quantity, I would go bot both ways. Nevertheless, quality is of utmost importance for me. I despise reading long content that does not make sense.

  6. Ah, the classic debate. Quantity and quality are both important, so it is always difficult to pick one over the other. As others have said, however, creating quantity goals is very important. In order to be successful you have to make readers keep coming back, and that can only happen if you keep producing content. Having a schedule of when to post ensures that you stay relevant and also forces you to sit down and write. While the first draft may not be high quality content, revision can take you there. The hardest part is usually starting!

  7. This is the key point: “Deadlines are the greatest source of inspiration.”

    Everyone should follow that rule very closely for best results. We need deadlines to keep us focused on creating content. Quality is something that needs to happen within a deadline timeframe. Deadlines help eliminate procrastination and force us to become better in smaller blocks of time. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *